BSC 1011C
General Biology II
Dr. Graeme Lindbeck
glindbeck@valenciacollege.edu


The Origins of Eukaryotic Diversity

Outline

A. Introduction to the Protists

  1. Systematists have split protists into many kingdoms
  2. Protists are the most diverse of all eukaryotes

B. The Origin and Early Diversification of Eukaryotes

  1. Endomembranes contributed to larger, more complex cells
  2. Mitochondria and plastids evolved from endosymbiotic bacteria
  3. The eukaryotic cell is a chimera of prokaryote ancestors
  4. Secondary endosymbiosis increased the diversity of algae
  5. Research on the relationships between the three domains is changing ideas about the deepest branching in the tree of life
  6. The origin of eukaryotes catalyzed a second great wave of diversification

C. A Sample of Protistan Diversity

  1. Diplomonadida and Parabasala: Diplomonads and parabasilids lack mitochondria
  2. Euglenozoa: The euglenozoa includes both photosynthetic and heterotrophic flagellates
  3. Alveolata: The alveolates are unicellular protists with subsurface cavities (alveoli)
  4. Stramenopila: The stramenopile clade that includes the water molds and heterokont algae
  5. Structural and biochemical adaptations help seaweeds survive and reproduce at the ocean's margins
  6. Some algae have life cycles with alternating multicellular haploid and diploid generations
  7. Rhodophyta: Red algae lack flagella
  8. Chlorophyta: Green algae and plants evolved from a common photoautotrophic ancestor
  9. A diversity of protists use pseudopodia for movement and feeding
  10. Mycetozoa: Slime molds have structural adaptations and life cycles that enhance their ecological roles as decomposers
  11. Multicellularity originated independently many times

Introduction

Protists are eukaryotes and thus are much more complex than the prokaryotes.

The first eukaryotes were unicellular.

The origin of the eukaryotic cell and the emergence of multicellularity unfolded during the evolution of protists.

Eukaryotic fossils date back 2.1 billion years and "chemical signatures" of eukaryotes date back 2.7 billion years.

For about 2 billion years, eukaryotes consisted of mostly microscopic organisms known by the informal name "protists."

1. Systematists have split protists into many kingdoms

In the five-kingdom system of classification, the eukaryotes were distributed among four kingdoms: Protista, Plantae, Fungi, and Animalia.

Protista was defined partly by structural level (mostly unicellular eukaryotes) and partly by exclusion from the definitions of plants, fungi, or animals.

However, this created a group ranging from single-celled microscopic members, simple multicellular forms, and complex giants like seaweeds.

The kingdom Protista formed a paraphyletic group, with some members more closely related to animals, plants, or fungi than to other protists.

Systematists have split the former kingdom Protista into as many as 20 separate kingdoms.

Still,"protist" is used as an informal term for this great diversity of eukaryotic kingdoms.

Back to top

2. Protists are the most diverse of all eukaryotes

Protists are so diverse that few general characteristics can be cited without exceptions.

Most of the 60,000 known protists are unicellular, but some are colonial and others multicellular.

While unicellular protists would seem to be the simplest eukaryotic organisms, at the cellular level they are the most elaborate of all cells.

Protists are the most nutritionally diverse of all eukaryotes.

Euglena, a single celled mixotrophic protist, can use chloroplasts to undergo photosynthesis if light is available or live as a heterotroph by absorbing organic nutrients from the environment.

These various modes of nutrition are scattered throughout the protists.

While nutrition is not a reliable taxonomic characteristic, it is useful in understanding the adaptations of protists and the roles that they play in biological communities.

Most protists move with flagella or cilia during some time in their life cycles.

The eukaryotic flagella are not homologous to those of prokaryotes.

Reproduction and life cycles are highly varied among protists.

Mitosis occurs in almost all protists, but there are many variations in the process.

Some protists are exclusively asexual or at least employ meiosis and syngamy (the union of two gametes), thereby shuffling genes between two individuals.

Others are primarily asexual but can also reproduce sexually at least occasionally.

Protists show the three basic types of sexual life cycles, with some other variants, too.

The haploid stage is the vegetative stage of most protists, with the zygote as the only diploid cell.

Many protists form resistant cells (cysts) that can survive harsh conditions.

Protists are found almost anywhere there is water.

Many protists are symbionts that inhabit the body fluids, tissues, or cells of hosts.

These symbiotic relationships span the continuum from mutualism to parasitism.

Back to top

B. The Origin and Early Diversification of Eukaryotes

The evolution of the eukaryotic cell led to the development of several unique cellular structures and processes.

These include:

1. Endomembranes contributed to larger, more complex cells

The small size and simple construction of a prokaryotes imposes limits on the number of different metabolic activities that can be accomplished at one time.

One trend was the evolution of multicellular prokaryotes, where cells specialized for different functions.

A second trend was the evolution of complex communities of prokaryotes, with species benefiting from the metabolic specialties of others.

A third trend was the compartmentalization of different functions within single cells, an evolutionary solution that contributed to the origins of eukaryotes.

Under one evolutionary scenario, the endomembrane system of eukaryotes (nuclear envelope, endoplasmic reticulum, Golgi apparatus, and related structures) may have evolved from infoldings of plasma membrane.

Another process, called endosymbiosis, probably led to mitochondria, plastids, and perhaps other eukaryotic features.

Back to top

2. Mitochondria and plastids evolved from endosymbiotic bacteria

The evidence is now overwhelming that the eukaryotic cell originated from a symbiotic coalition of multiple prokaryotic ancestors.

A mechanism for this was originated by a Russian biologist C. Mereschkovsky and developed extensively by Lynn Margulis of the University of Massachusetts.

The theory of serial endosymbiosis proposes that mitochondria and chloroplasts were formerly small prokaryotes living within larger cells.

The proposed ancestors of mitochondria were aerobic heterotrophic prokaryotes.

The proposed ancestors of chloroplasts were photosynthetic prokaryotes.

These ancestors probably entered the host cells as undigested prey or internal parasites.

This evolved into a mutually beneficial symbiosis.

As host and endosymbiont evolved, both would become more interdependent, evolving into a single organism, its parts inseparable.

The serial endosymbiosis theory supposes that mitochondria evolved before chloroplasts.

Many examples of symbiotic relationships among modern organisms are analogous to proposed early stages of the serial endosymbiotic theory.

Several lines of evidence support a close similarity between bacteria and the chloroplasts and mitochondria of eukaryotes.

A comprehensive theory for the origin of the eukaryotic cell must also account for the evolution of the cytoskeleton and the 9 + 2 microtubule apparatus of the eukaryotic cilia and flagella.

Related to the evolution of the eukaryotic flagellum is the origin of mitosis and meiosis, processes unique to eukaryotes that also employ microtublules.

Back to top

3. The eukaryotic cell is a chimera of prokaryotic ancestors

The chimera of Greek mythology was part goat, part lion, and part serpent.

Similarly, the eukaryotic cell is a chimera of prokaryotic parts:

The search for the closest living prokaryotic relatives to the eukaryotic cell has been based on molecular comparisons because no morphological homologies connect species so diverse.

While mitochondria and plastids contain DNA and can build proteins, they are not genetically self-sufficient.

A reasonable hypothesis for the collaboration between the genomes of the organelles and the nucleus is that the endosymbionts transferred some of their DNA to the host genome during the evolutionary transition from symbiosis to integrated eukaryotic organism.

Back to top

4. Secondary endosymbiosis increased the diversity of algae

Taxonomic groups with plastids are scattered throughout the phylogenetic tree of eukaryotes.

These plastids vary in ultrastructure.

The best current explanation for this diversity of plastids is that plastids were acquired independently several times during the early evolution of eukaryotes.

Each endosymbiotic event adds a membrane derived from the vacuole membrane of the host cell that engulfed the endosymbiont.

In most cases of secondary endosymbiosis, the endosymbiont lost most of its parts, except its plastid.

In some algae, there are remnants of the secondary endosymbionts.

Back to top

5. Research on the relationships between the three domains is changing ideas about the deepest branching in the tree of life

The chimeric origin of the eukaryotic cells contrasts with the classic Darwinian view of lineal descent through a "vertical" series of ancestors.

The conventional model of relationships among the three domains place the archaea as more closely related to eukaryotes than they are to prokaryotes.

The conventional cladogram predicts that the only DNA of bacterial origin in the nucleus of eukaryotes are genes that were transferred from the endosymbionts that evolved into mitochondria and plastids.

Surprisingly, systematists have found many DNA sequences in the nuclear genome of eukaryotes that have no role in mitochondria or chloroplasts.

Also, modern archaea have many genes of bacterial origin.

All three domains seem to have genomes that are chimeric mixes of DNA that was transferred across the boundaries of the domains.

This has lead some researchers to suggest replacing the classical tree with a web-like phylogeny

In this new model, the three domains arose from an ancestral community of primitive cells that swapped DNA promiscuously.

Back to top

6. The origin of eukaryotes catalyzed a second great wave of diversification

The first great adaptive radiation, the metabolic diversification of the prokaryotes, set the stage for the second.

The second wave of diversification was catalyzed by the greater structural diversity of the eukaryotic cell.

The third wave of diversification followed the origin of multicellular bodies in several eukaryotic lineages.

The diversity of eukaryotes ranges from a great variety of unicellular forms to such macroscopic, multicellular groups as brown algae, plants, fungi, and animals.

The development of clades among the diverse groups of eukaryotes is based on comparisons of cell structure, life cycles, and molecules.

If plants, animals, and fungi are designated as kingdoms, then each of the other major clades of eukaryotes probably deserve kingdom status as well.

Back to top

C: A Sample of Protistan Diversity

1. Diplomonadida and Parabasala: Diplomonads and parabasalids lack mitochondria

A few protists, including the diplomonds and the parabasalids, lack mitochondria.

According to the "archaezoa hypothesis," these protists are derived from ancient eukaryotic lineages before the acquisition of endosymbiotic bacteria that evolved into mitochondria.

This evidence suggests a new hypothesis, that these protists lost their mitochondria during their evolution.

Other details of cell structure and data from molecular systematics still place the diplomonads and parablastids on the phylogenetic branch that diverged earliest in eukaryotic history.

The diplomonads have multiple flagella, two separate nuclei, a simply cytoskeleton, and no mitochondria or plastids.

One example is Giardia lamblia, a parasite that infects the human intestine.

The parabasalids include trichomonads.

The best known species, Trichomonas vaginalis, inhabits the vagina of human females.

Back to top

2. Euglenozoa: The euglenozoa includes both photosynthetic and heterotrophic flagellates

Several protistan groups, including the euglenoids and kinetoplastids, use flagella for locomotion.

The euglenoids (Euglenozoa) are characterized by an anterior pocket from which one or two flagella emerge.

The kinetoplastids (Kinoplastida) have a single large mitochondrion associated with a unique organelle, the kinetoplast.

Kinetoplastids are symbiotic and include pathogenic parasites.

For example, Trypanosoma causes African sleeping sickness.

Back to top

3. Alveolata: The alveolata are unicellular protists with subcellular cavities (alveoli)

The Alveolata combines flagellated protists (dinoflagellates), parasites (apicomplexans), and ciliated protists (the ciliates).

Members of this clade have alveoli, small membrane-bound cavities, under the cell surface.

The dinoflagellates are abundant components of the phytoplankton that are suspended near the water surface.

Each dinoflagellate species has a characteristic shape, often reinforced by internal plates of cellulose.

Two flagella sit in perpendicular grooves in the "armor" and produce a spinning movement.

Dinoflagellate blooms, characterized by explosive population growth, cause red tides in coastal waters.

One dangerous dinoflagellate, Pfiesteria piscicida, is actually carnivorous.

Some dinoflagellates form mutualistic symbioses with cnidarians, animals that build coral reefs.

Some dinoflagellates are bioluminescent.

All apicomplexans are parasites of animals and some cause serious human diseases.

Plasmodium, the parasite that causes malaria, spends part of its life in mosquitoes and part in humans.

The incidence of malaria was greatly diminished in the 1960s by the use of insecticides against the Anopheles mosquitoes, which spread the disease, and by drugs that killed the parasites in humans.

Research has had little success in producing a malarial vaccine because Plasmodium is evasive.

Identification of a gene that may confer resistance to chloroquine, an antimalarial drug, may lead to ways to block drug resistance in Plasmodium.

A second promising approach may attack a nonphotosynthetic plastid in Plasmodium.

The Ciliophora (ciliates), a diverse protist group, is named for their use of cilia to move and feed.

Most ciliates live as solitary cells in freshwater.

Their cilia are associated with a submembrane system of microtubules that may coordinate movement.

In a Paramecium, cilia along the oral groove draw in food that are engulfed by phagocytosis.

Like other freshwater protists, the hyperosmotic Paramecium expels accumulated water from the contractile vacuole.

Ciliates have two types of nuclei, a large macronucleus and usually several tiny micronuclei.

The sexual shuffling of genes occurs during conjugation, during which micronuclei that have undergone meiosis are exchanged.

Back to top

4. Stramenopila: The stramenopila clade includes the water molds and heterokont algae

The Stramenopila includes both heterotrophic and photosynthetic protists.

The heterotrophic stramenopiles, the oomycotes, include water molds, white rusts, and downy mildews.

In the Oomycota, the "egg fungi", a relatively large egg cell is fertilized by a smaller "sperm nucleus," forming a resistant zygote.

Water molds are important decomposers, mainly in fresh water.

White rusts and downy mildews are parasites of terrestrial plants.

The photosynthetic stramenopile taxa are known collectively as the heterokont algae.

The plastids of these algae evolved by secondary endosymbiosis.

The heterokont algae include diatoms, golden algae, and brown algae.

Diatoms (Bacillariophyta) have unique glasslike walls composed of hydrated silica embedded in an organic matrix.

Most of the year, diatoms reproduce asexually by mitosis with each daughter cell receiving half of the cell wall and regenerating a new second half.

Some species form cysts as resistant stages.

Sexual stages are not common, but sperm may be amoeboid or flagellated, depending on species.

Diatoms are abundant members of both freshwater and marine plankton.

Golden algae (Chrysophyta), named for the yellow and brown carotene and xanthophyll pigments, are typically biflagellated.

Some species are mixotrophic and many live among freshwater and marine plankton.
While most are unicellular, some are colonial.

At high densities, they can form resistant cysts that remain viable for decades.

Brown algae (Phaeophyta) are the largest and most complex algae.

Brown algae are especially common along temperate coasts in areas of cool water and adequate nutrients.

They owe their characteristic brown or olive color to accessory pigments in the plastids.

Back to top

5. Structural and biochemical adaptations help seaweeds survive and reproduce at the ocean's margins

The largest marine algae, including brown, red, and green algae, are known collectively as seaweeds.

Seaweeds inhabit the intertidal and subtidal zones of coastal waters.

Seaweeds have a complex multicellular anatomy, with some differentiated tissues and organs that resemble those in plants.

Some brown algae have floats to raise the blades toward the surface.

Many seaweeds have biochemical adaptations for intertidal and subtidal conditions.

Many seaweeds are eaten by coastal people, including Laminaria ("kombu" in Japan) and Porphyra (Japanese "nori") for sushi wraps.

A variety of gelforming substances are extracted in commercial operations.

Back to top

6. Some algae have life cycles with alternating multicellular haploid and diploid generations

The multicellular brown, red, and green algae show complex life cycles with alternation of multicellular haploid and multicellular diploid forms.

The life cycle of the brown alga Laminaria is an example of alternation of generations.

The diploid individual, the sporophyte, produces haploid spores (zoospores) by meiosis.

The haploid individual, the gametophyte, produces gametes by mitosis that fuse to form a diploid zygote.

In Laminaria, the sporophyte and gametophyte are structurally different, called heteromorphic.

In other algae, the alternating generations look alike (isomorphic), but they differ in the number of chromosomes.

Back to top

7. Rhodophyta: Red algae lack flagella

Unlike other eukaryotic algae, red algae have no flagellated stages in their life cycle.

The red coloration visible in many members is due to the accessory pigment phycoerythrin.

The plastids of red algae evolved from primary endosymbiosis of cyanobacteria.

Some species lack pigmentation and are parasites on other red algae.

Red algae (Rhodophyta) are the most common seaweeds in the warm coastal waters of tropical oceans.

Some red algae inhabit deeper waters than other photosynthetic eukaryotes.

Most red algae are multicellular, with some reaching a size to be called "seaweeds".

The life cycles of red algae are especially diverse.

Back to top

8. Chlorophyta: Green algae and plants evolved from a common photoautotrophic ancestor

Green algae (chlorophytes and charophyceans) are named for their grass-green chloroplasts.

The charophyceans are especially closely related to land plants.

Most of the 7,000 species of chlorophytes live in freshwater.

Chlorophytes range in complexity, including:

Large size and complexity in chlorophytes has evolved by three different mechanisms:

  1. formation of colonies of individual cells (Volvox)
  2. the repeated division of nuclei without cytoplasmic division to form multinucleate filaments (Caulerpa)
  3. formation of true multicellular forms by cell division and cell differentiation (Ulva).

Most green algae have both sexual and asexual reproductive stages.

Photosynthetic protists have evolved in several clades that also have heterotrophic members.

Different episodes of secondary endosymbiosis account for the diversity of protists with plastids.

Back to top

9. A diversity of protists use pseudopodia for movement and feeding

Three groups of protists use pseudopodia, cellular extensions, to move and often to feed.

Rhizopods (amoebas) are all unicellular and use pseudopodia to move and to feed.

Pseudopodium emerge from anywhere in the cell surface.

Amoeboid movement is driven by changes in microtubules and microfilaments in the cytoskeleton.

Pseudopodia activity is not random but in fact directed toward food.

In some species pseudopodia extend out through openings in a protein shell around the organism.

Amoebas inhabit freshwater and marine environments

Most species are free-living heterotrophs.

Some are important parasites.

Actinopod (heliozoans and radiolarians), "ray foot," refers to slender pseudopodia (axopodia) that radiate from the body.

Most actinopods are planktonic.

Most heliozoans ("sun animals") live in fresh water.

The term radiolarian refers to several groups of mostly marine actinopods.

Foraminiferans, or forams, are almost all marine.

Pseudopodia extend through the pores for swimming, shell formation, and feeding.

Over ninety percent of the described forams are fossils.

Back to top

10. Mycetozoa: Slime molds have structural adaptations and life cycles that enhance their ecological roles as decomposers

Mycetozoa (slime molds or "fungus animals") are neither fungi nor animals, but protists.

Slime molds feed and move via pseudopodia, like amoeba, but comparisons of protein sequences place slime molds relatively close to the fungi and animals.

The plasmodial slime molds (Myxogastrida) are brightly pigmented, heterotrophic organisms.

The feeding stage is an amoeboid mass, the plasmodium, that may be several centimeters in diameter.

The diploid nuclei undergo synchronous mitotic divisions, perhaps thousands at a time.

Within the cytoplasm, cytoplasmic streaming distributes nutrients and oxygen throughout the plasmodium.

The plasmodium phagocytises food particles from moist soil, leaf mulch, or rotting logs.

If the habitat begins to dry or if food levels drop, the plasmodium differentiates into stages that lead to sexual reproduction.

The cellular slime molds (Dictyostelida) straddle the line between individuality and multicellularity.

The dominant stage in a cellular slime mold is the haploid stage.

Back to top

11. Multicellularity originated independently many times

The origin of unicellular eukaryotes permitted more structural diversity than was possible for prokaryotes.

This ignited an explosion of biological diversification.

The evolution of multicellular bodies and the possibility of even greater structural diversity, triggered another wave of diversification.

Back to top

Course Pages maintained by
Dr. Graeme Lindbeck .